MLB Baseball: New York Yankees vs. New York Mets Preview, Prediction & Odds - Sept. 11, 2021

by Chuck Sommers

Game time: 7:45 p.m. ET
Venue: Citi Field, Flushing, NY
Where to watch: FOX

Opening Odds at USA Sportsbooks

DraftKings: Yankees -120, Mets +100
Caesars: NL

Season record (entering Friday)
Yankees: 78-62 (3rd place, AL East)
Mets: 70-71 (3rd place, NL East)

Larry Ness is caught in a 3-day MLB slump (just 2-6) but this 38-year vet has not slumped very often. He's gone 159-116, +$27,417 with all plays since May 15 (4-month span) and checks in having earned a profit of $23,690 (at $100/unit) since Opening Day. His 3-game Friday card is highlighted by this 10* Division Game of the Month. Catch Larry’s and other plays available right now at the Shop Picks page, where you can find all of the Best Bets from our champion sports handicappers.

Yankees - Mets preview and analysis

Recent form
Yankees: Lost 6 straight
Mets: 6-4 in last 10

Welcome to the latest edition of the Subway Series featuring two New York teams that have defied all logic in the last few days, for better or worse.

Mostly worse.

The New York Yankees and New York Mets enter this weekend’s three-game series at Citi Field with the same collective goal in mind: don’t screw it up.

A series loss for the Mets will likely take them out of the race for the National League East, ending all hopes for a postseason run. If the Yankees lose this series after getting blasted in four games by the Toronto Blue Jays, it may be DEFCON 1 in the Bronx.

The Yankees, by way of their six-game losing streak entering Friday for the first game of the series, not only has fallen well out of favor for the American League East crown but no longer holds home-field advantage in the AL Wild Card race. The Boston Red Sox have jumped their arch-rivals and the one-game playoff would be at Fenway Park if the playoffs started today.

And speaking of the Blue Jays, that sweep has put them a half-game behind the Yankees heading into Friday. So if the Yankees continue to slip up, the Blue Jays could pass them by this weekend seeing how Toronto is in Baltimore.

To top it off, Gerrit Cole is dealing with hamstring issues and could be out for a little bit. That tests New York’s pitching depth, and that starts with Corey Kluber getting the start for Game 2 of this three-game Subway Series on Saturday. The former Cy Young winner is 4-3 with a 3.69 ERA this season.

The Mets have found new life with a solid start to September and a well-run close to August. But also thanks to the San Diego Padres’ roller coaster of a season, the Mets have found life in the NL Wild Card race, trailing both the National League East race and the wild card race by five games. The Mets have also benefitted during the Atlanta Braves’ slide following their nine-game winning streak.

Taijuan Walker will take the mound for the Mets, who enter Friday losers of three of four after winning seven of their previous eight. The right-handed pitcher is 7-9 with a 4.15 ERA this season.


I have no idea what to make of what the Yankees are dealing with right now, whether it’s something that can be corrected or it’s something worse. It wasn’t long ago they were the hottest team in baseball, and that’s why they should be considered the chance to win. I’ll go against the grain and take the Mets in a close one. Walker has lost his last six decisions with the last win coming July 3 against these same Yankees. The Mets have turned it around a bit offensively and may have found a formula that works. The Subway Series always turns out a good crowd, and this one should be no different. Mets win 6-4.

Betting trends

The Yankees are 28-30 when a favorite of -125 to -175.

The Mets are 22-29 (-8.8 net games on the moneyline) when it’s between +125 and -125

Key injuries

Yankees: SP Gerrit Cole (hamstring, day-to-day), SP Jameson Taillon (10-day IL)

Mets: None

Players to watch

Yankees: The Joey Gallo Experience has been that. The trade deadline acquisition from the Texas Rangers is batting just .091 in his last 20 games entering Friday with two home runs and having struck out 33 times.

Mets: Star slugger Pete Alonso enters Friday with a nine-game hitting streak and hits in 10 of his last 11. In September, Alonso is batting .389 with three homers and eight RBI, as the Mets have gone 5-4 during the streak.

Projected lineup

Brett Gardner (L) CF
Aaron Judge (R) LF
Anthony Rizzo (L) 1B
Giancarlo Stanton (R) RF
Gleyber Torres (R) SS
Joey Gallo (L) 3B
Gary Sanchez (R) C
Tyler Wade (L) 2B
Corey Kluber (R) P

Jonathan Villar (S) 3B
Francisco Lindor (S) SS
Michael Conforto (L) RF
Pete Alonso (R) 1B
Javier Baez (R) 2B
Jeff McNeil (L) LF
Kevin Pillar (R) CF
James McCann (R) C
Taijuan Walker (R) P

Statistical leaders

Batting average: Aaron Judge (.294)
Hits: DJ LeMahieu (142)
Home runs: Aaron Judge (30)
RBI: Aaron Judge (75)
Stolen bases: Gleyber Torres (12)
Wins: Gerrit Cole (14)
Saves: Aroldis Chapman (25)
ERA: Gerrit Cole (2.78)

Batting average: Pete Alonso (.269)
Hits: Pete Alonso (130)
Home runs: Pete Alonso (32)
RBI: Pete Alonso (84)
Stolen bases: Jonathan Villar (12)
Wins: Marcus Stroman (9)
Saves: Edwin Diaz (28)
ERA: Marcus Stroman (2.87)

Don't miss our champion handicappers' free picks and expert MLB picks today. And if you enjoyed this NY Yankees - New York Mets prediction, be sure to drop by every day for our daily MLB projections and previews.

Chuck Sommers

About the Author:

Chuck Sommers has camped outside of sportsbooks since he can remember, learning the tricks and nuances of the trade. He still has nightmares of betting $5,000 on the Raiders in the Tuck Rule game but has since turned that to 25 years of veteran handicapping greatness. You can find him mostly in the shadows at the Red Rock or Aliante casinos wondering if the over is cashing on any given Sunday.

All photographic images used for editorial content have been licensed from the Associated Press.

© 2022 Al McMordie's All Rights Reserved.