Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees Game Prediction, Odds and Preview - 10/11/2022

by James Q

Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees Game Prediction, Odds and Preview - 10/11/2022 

Game Time: 7:37 pm ET, Tuesday, October 11th, 2022
Venue: Yankee Stadium, Bronx, New York
Where to Watch:  TBS Television

Opening MLB Odds at USA Sportsbooks

DraftKings: Moneyline:  NYY -205, CLE +175, O/U 7 Runs
BetMGM:  Moneyline:  NYY -200, CLE +170, O/U 6.5 Runs
BetRivers:  Moneyline:  NYY -200, CLE +175, O/U, 7 Runs

Season Record

Guardians: 92-70, 1st place AL Central.
Yankees: 99-63, 1st place Al East.

The American League Divisional Series gets underway with a surprise entry.  We all knew the New York Yankees would be here... They got the bye and have been having a great season.  Yet how many of us started this season thinking the Guardians would be here?... How many of us started the season thinking the Guardians would be in the postseason at all?  Also how many of us started the season calling the Guardians the Indians out of simple reflex and mouth muscle memory?  It's the Guardians and they are for real... But are they real enough to battle the Bronx Bombers?

The Cleveland Guardians have just an average offensive attack.  They finished 16th in runs scored which is literally at league average.  Cleveland's pitchers have been the star of the show... Top 6 in the league in every major category.  Manager Terry Francona would like nothing more than to get out to a lead in this series.  The opening game will be of utmost importance... and for a team with these numbers they will also need a fair amount of the ball bouncing the right way.

The New York Yankees have better numbers than the Guardians across the board.  They are 2nd only to the Dodgers in runs scored per game... and start a line-up with some very powerful home run hitters to rely on.   Slugger Aaron Judge finished the season with 62 homers... he captured the non-steroid home run record... which many believe is the true home run record.  He is good for a long ball at seemingly anytime... but you can't also overlook Staton... The highly paid mercenary that came out of Florida a couple of seasons ago to play the Dave Winfield role to Judge's Reggie Jackson.  Lots of people think that Stanton is not long for the Yankees especially if the Yankees spend this offseason dropping $40 million per season on a long deal with Judge.  However that is not now... Stanton has is a hard hitting postseason away from becoming a Yankee immortal and he has all the talent to do it.  The Yankees pitching rotation also has better numbers than the Guardians... 3rd in ERA, 3rd in WHIP... They scoff at top six.

The Yankees are heavily favored for a reason.  The Yankees are at home.  The Yankees are in the postseason.

AAA Sports is 4-1 in MLB picks over the last 7 days for a profit of +$3,150!! You should be following along with the expert handicappers at Get AAA Sport’s picks… It's available right now at the Shop Picks page, where you can find all of the Best Bets from our champion sports handicappers. You can also get help with all your favorite sports and sport betting.., MLB, NBA, NCAAF, NFL, NHL.  Follow a handicapper all year long to ensure a profitable year from your sports betting.

Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees Review and Analysis

Recent Form


Offensive Analysis

Cleveland finished the season 16th in runs scored per game with 4.31, 7th in batting average with .254, and 12th in OBP with .316.

The Yankees finished the season 2nd in runs scored with 4.98 per game, 15th in batting average with .241, and 5th in OBP with .325.  The Yankees have that great scoring average that has been built on Aaron Judge home runs and Giancarlo Stanton home runs… that is why the batting average is… just average.  Still if you walk a Yankee… you have to worry about him getting hit in.

Defensive Analysis

Cleveland’s pitchers finished the season 6th in ERA with 3.47, 5th in WHIP with 1.16, and the fielders are 5th in errors with only 75 on the season.

The Yankees Pitchers finished the season 3rd in ERA with 3.30, 3rd in WHIP with 1.12, and their fielders are 7th in errors with 79 on the season.

Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees Prediction

Our prediction for Tuesday, October 11th is… Yankees 6 - Guardians 2

The Yankees get the home field advantage and the initial pitching matchup.  Bet on the Yankees to win on the moneyline.  The Yankees winning Game 1 in no means warrants giving up in the Guardians.  In fact the Yankees have been bad during the last two months of the season… so The Guardians have a decent puncher’s chance.  Still first home game in the playoffs is to the Yankees' advantage.

Don't miss our champion handicappers' Free MLB Picks and Premium Selections every day here at Just click on Shop Picks for our Best Bets, or click on Shop Subscriptions to join for a week or a month. And if you enjoyed this Guardians/Yankees preview, be sure to bookmark for our daily Game Previews and Predictions. 

MLB Betting Trends

Cleveland is 59-39 (+18.0 Net Games) off a win
Cleveland is 16-2 (+15.8 Net Games) behind Paul Quantrill
New York is 14-15 (-19.1 Net Games) as a home favorite of -150+ behind Gerrit Cole
New York is 23-14 Over at home its last 37


Players to Watch

Cleveland Guardians TBD
Yankees TBD

Starting Lineups
Guardians: LF Steven Kwan, SS Amed Rosario, 3B Jose Ramirez, RF Oscar Gonzalez, 1B Josh Naylor, DH Owen Miller, 2B Andres Giminez, C Austin Hedges, CF Myles Straw

Yankees: 2B DJ LaMahieu, 1B Anthony Rizzo, LF Oswaldo Cabrera, 3B Josh Donaldson, SS Oswald Peraze, DH Aaron Judge, RF Marwin Gonzalez, C Kyle Higashioka, CF Aaron Hicks


Guardians: Terry “Let’s make history” Francona
Yankees: Aaron “I am history” Boone

Weather Forecast 

Sunny, 70*, Humidity 53%, Wind 7 mph.  

James Q

About the Author:

James Q. has been involved with sports and gambling his entire life. A former division 1 scholarship basketball player, James understands sports (and especially basketball) inside-and-out. Following his basketball playing days, James parlayed his gambling skills into a semi-pro poker career. James resides in Los Angeles, and especially loves the Los Angeles Clippers, Los Angeles Rams, and Los Angeles Dodgers. And when he isn't betting on sports (and writing about it), James can be found performing stand-up comedy on the Sunset Strip.

All photographic images used for editorial content have been licensed from the Associated Press.

© 2023 Al McMordie's All Rights Reserved.